Johnathan married Sarah Elizabeth STEINER on 14 Dec 1874 in Scotch Valley, Pennsylvania. Sarah (daughter of Henry Frederick STEINER and Lydia MICHAEL) was born on 29 Oct 1856 in Mifflinville, Pennsylvania, United States; died on 1 Mar 1923 in Atkinson, Henry, Illinois, United States; was buried on 4 Mar 1923 in Atkinson, Henry, Illinois, United States. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

1. Charles Abraham MACAFEE was born in Feb 1875 in Pennsylvania, United States; died on 5 Jul 1925 in Atkinson, Henry, Illinois, United States.
2. Scone MACAFEE was born in 1877 in Pennsylvania, United States; and died.
3. William J MACAFEE was born in Aug 1880 in Pennsylvania, United States; and died.
4. Franklin J MACAFEE was born in Sep 1884 in Pennsylvania, United States; and died.
5. Sarah Leona MACAFEE was born on 4 Jul 1887 in Atkinson, Henry, Illinois, United States; died on 1 Jan 1926 in Geneseo, Henry, Illinois, United States; was buried in Oakwood Cemetery, Geneseo, Henry, Illinois, United States.
6. Ruth B MACAFEE was born in Dec 1894 in Illinois, United States; and died.